Old Bethpage, NY Real Estate

Old Bethpage NY Real Estate Overview




Open Houses


Short Sales







Old Bethpage NY Real Estate Stats

Average Price in Old Bethpage: $813,095 / County Average: $1,121,852

Average Taxes in Old Bethpage: $13,935 / County Average: $22,327

Average Cost Per Sqr Ft in Old Bethpage: $328 / County Average: $378

Average Walkscore in Old Bethpage: 31 / County Average: 52

Average Year Built in Old Bethpage: 1972 / County Average: 1959

Average Days on Website in Old Bethpage: 43 / County Average: 88

Old Bethpage NY Real Estate Market Health

Neighborhood in Old Bethpage NY

Oyster Bay

Areas in Old Bethpage NY

Seton Hills

Most Popular Listing

Popular Old Bethpage Real Estate

Most Expensive Listing

Expensive Old Bethpage Real Estate

Least Expensive Listing

Cheap Old Bethpage Real Estate

Listings in Old Bethpage

Fully, completely renovated split in the heart of Old Bethpage bright over sized ...

Wow!! this magnificent 2300 sq ft move in ready home offers gleaming hardwood wood floors, bright & sunny eat in kitchen, granite counter tops, gas cooking & sliders to a beautiful trek deck and stunning park like property, 5 bedrooms 2...

Prime seton hills beautiful cape cod. features over sized bedrooms, updated kitchen w/ stainless steel appliances, updated bathrooms with radiant heat floors...

exquisite millwork w/amazing attention to details & superb workmanship! Old Bethpage elem! time to customize! pics are not exact-only examples of finished homes from this builder....

This is the home you have been waiting for! this beautiful seton hills split has an eik, hardwood floors, central air, fireplace, newer windows, roof and gas burner, near hiking trail...

Dar closet and excessive storage.multi car drvwy. Old Bethpage elementary,mattlin middle school....

nice private yard, over sized driveway. this home offers plainview-Old Bethpage schools. room for large family. this home has a 2 large eat in kitchens, 4 baths, new flooring throughout, all new fencing, siding ...

Enormous center hall colonial perfect for large family that likes to entertain-new custom eik-lr-dr with brazilian cherry hw floors-separate family room features built ins & fireplace-inviting master suite w wic & jacuzzi tub-4 additional bedrooms and 2 full baths-full finished basement-2 car garage-ig pool and sprinklers-cac-this home has it all ...

Tax grievance in place-magazine quality remodeled spacious & lovely colonial features all oversized rooms-open floor plan-living rm w gas fireplace-fdr-new cherry eik with gas cooking and all new ss appliances- quartz counters-french sliders to yard-new main level bath -king master bedroom suite with full 4 piece new bath w dbl sink & wic-2 additional bedrooms and new full bath-full finished basement-mostly all updated andersen windows-3 zone gas heat-just move right in...

One of a kind brand new center hall colonial 3580 sq ft of quality craftsmanship...

master has private bath, updated family bath, cozy den with brick walled fireplace, large eik. plainview- Old Bethpage school district! stratford elementary. easy distance to worship. will not last!...

minutes from lirr hicksville station. plainview Old Bethpage schools. parkway elementary, mattlin middle and kennedy high....

Diamond split in the prestigious plainview-Old Bethpage school district...

H patio, cac, gas heat, 1 gar garage. plainview / Old Bethpage schools....

gorgeous eik w/stainless appliances, hw floors, gas fireplace, open concept floorplan, 9' basement ceiling with ose, igs.2 car garage, desirable plainview-Old Bethpage schools....

move right into this pristine home in the highly rated plainview-Old Bethpage school district....

Look no further! this exquisite home is set on your own mini estate...

Privacy abounds in this beautiful 4 bedroom 2-1/2 bath colonial...

Quintessential mcm split-level in desirable Old Bethpage, fronting trailview state park...

3 bedroom split in seton hills, updated bthrooms, 5 year roof, alarm, central vac, immaculate condition, beautiful backyard with waterfall and built in barbq...

Property Search

Saved Properties

This is a list of your favorite properties. We will email you if a property is reduced or leaves the market.

Click 'Save' to add a property to this list.

Register / Login

New & returning visitors please enter your information to login.

By clicking 'register' you are agreeing to our terms of use & giving us expressed written consent to contact you.

Questions? Comments? Complaints?

This message will go directly to the head of our team.

Location & Address

Charles D’Agostino
1979 Marcus Avenue Suite 210
Lake Success, NY